SUBMISSION
Panel: Balancing the Need for rapid Sharing with the Need for rigorous Evaluation – the Role of Preprints and Peer Review - Panelist Rebecca Lawrence
11 views
3 downloads
Video
Presentation
Abstract
Many differing forms of pre-review publication followed by a range of post-publication peer review approaches, both transparent and closed, have recently been developed. This short presentation will provide a summary of some of these approaches, and highlight key features and advantages of differing approaches, in particular as they relate to trust in science and societal benefit of research.
Discussion
Ask a Question
Get involved to find out more about this Presentation.
All Comments
Log In to participate in the discussion
DS
Deborah J. Sweet
Jan 13, 2021 at 02:58 PMWhat do the panelists think about the concept of requiring preprint deposition, as some funders (and even journals) have done?
AW
Anthony Watkinson
Jan 13, 2021 at 02:58 PMI missed most of the beginning point but did heae Rebecca's very cogent talk.. The evidence some of which comes from our work(CIBER Research) demonstrates that researchers in general are pretty clear that a publication is a peer reviewed article. Why not accept this?
PP
Prof. Dr. Bernd Pulverer
Jan 13, 2021 at 03:01 PM· Edited
question for Rebecca: you rightly emphasize importance of not loosing critical referee reports in transparent processes - but not all report are well founded/accurate. Should editors judge which reports are publically visible? Can referee cross-commenting ensure balance of opinions? Should we ensure that author responses are always linked to referee reports?
Rick Anderson
Jan 13, 2021 at 03:02 PMLet's bear in mind, too, that the world isn't divided between those who think OA is always best and therefore support it, and those who think it's worthless and therefore don't. Most opinion is more nuanced, I think, and the same is true of attitudes toward preprints. No solution poses nothing but upsides (or downsides).
Powered by
Discover more research and events on morressier.com