Inclusion of pesticide monitoring data in pesticide risk assessment is important yet challenging for several reasons, including: infrequent or irregular data collection, disparate sources procedures and associated monitoring periods, and interpretation of the data itself in a policy context. These challenges alone, left unaddressed, will likely introduce unintentional and unforeseen risk assessment conclusions. While individual water quality monitoring programs report standard operating procedures and quality control practices for their own data, cross-checking data for duplicated data from one database to another does not routinely occur. Consequently, we developed a novel quality control and assurance methodology to identify errors and duplicated records towards creating an aggregated, single pesticide database toward use in ecological risk assessment. This methodology includes 1) standardization and reformatting practices, 2) data error and duplicate record identification protocols, 3) missing or inconsistent limit of detection and quantification reporting, and 4) site metadata scoring and ranking procedures to flag likely duplicate records. We applied this methodology to develop an aggregated (multiple source), national-scale database for atrazine from a diverse set of surface water monitoring programs. The resultant database resolved and/or removed approximately 31% of the total ~385,000 records that were due to duplicated records. Identification of sample replicates was also developed. While the quality control and assurances methodologies developed in this work were applied to atrazine, they generally demonstrate how a properly constructed and aggregated single pesticide database would benefit from the methods described herein before use in subsequent statistical and data analysis or risk assessment.

Development of a mixed-source, single pesticide database for use in ecological risk assessment: Quality control and data standardization practices

ACS Spring 2022

The official archive and repository for all ACS Meetings & Expositions abstracts and select posters or presentations.